The four productions of William Shakespeare’s Othello I have seen are defined not by the quality of the acting (all were magnificent) but by the subtle shadings of the characters. In the 1970s, I saw a performance with James Earl Jones as Othello and Christopher Plummer as Iago.
The play was presented not as a straightforward morality fable about jealousy but about how the emotional vulnerability of Othello -- out of his element as a Moorish general married to a young Venetian woman -- is exploited by the resolutely evil Iago. The outcome seemed almost preordained, as if nothing the noble Othello could do would change it. His fallibility was seemingly inevitable.
I saw a different Iago when Patrick Page played him against Avery Brooks’ Othello. He was still malignant, but more human: A calculating and cool schemer who meticulously laid his traps for his commander. Page’s Iago was more sneaky and subtle than Plummer’s. Brooks played Othello as supremely confident but unaware of, or careless for, his credulity and vulnerability. His demise did not seem inevitable, only predictable if he did not wise up and realize he was being manipulated.
Some literary critics have emphasized Othello’s foreignness and his struggle to adapt to Western Christian culture. These critics have focused on the gender and racial aspects of the play. The most interesting production of Othello I have seen was one with an all-Black cast -- except for Othello, who was played by Patrick Stewart, and whose concept it was to have a “race- reversed” cast. The language of the play was not altered, however. Othello still says, “Haply for I am black” and “Her name, that was so fresh / As Dian’s visage is now begrimed and black / As my own face.”
Although the acting in the Stewart production was superb, and I enjoyed the conceptual conceit immensely, I thought putting the spotlight on racial identity detracted from the psychological heft of the play. To me, Shakespeare’s central point is larger than identity politics. Othello isn’t principally about gender, race or even jealousy. It’s about emotional vulnerability to evil -- what circumstances can cause it, nurture it and ultimately destroy the person who fails to heed the evil intent directed at him.
In the fourth production I saw, Jake Gyllenhaal gave Iago a refreshing look at the villain against Denzel Washington’s Othello. Gyllenhaal was intense and brooding, carrying his own psychological baggage after being passed over for promotion by his friend and longtime comrade- in-arms -- and seeing Othello happily married to the beautiful and virtuous Desdemona. Washington’s Othello is not so much blustery and confident as slow to recognize his predicament and vulnerability, and then quick to react (or overreact) when he thinks he’s been deceived by Desdemona.
Gyllenhaal’s Iago is not hated from first to last as he is in most productions. At first, he is witty -- even sympathetic -- addressing the audience in confidence. He only gradually emerges as a vengeful psychopath as Othello is shown to be the wronged and manipulated friend.
I find it hard to choose which interpretation of Othello I like the best. That, I believe, is a tribute to Shakespeare, as well as to the actors and directors of those marvelous productions.